What Causes the Gear Shift to Get Stuck

What Causes the Gear Shift to Get Stuck [How to Fix with 10 Steps]

Did you know that a few years ago, the FCA, otherwise known as the Fiat Chrysler Automobiles, summoned back more than 180,000 ram trucks?

I don’t know about the rest, but I would’ve hated to be one of those owners. In the 1990s, the shifter interlock came in as a safety feature; however, now, we seem to want ways to avoid and rectify it. The good news is that even with changing times, we’re not entirely hopeless regarding stuck gear shifts.

All we need to do is find ways to avoid and eradicate the issue. However, first, we must identify what causes the gear shift to get stuck, and only then can we target the faulty spot and implement a solution. So, are you ready to put yourself and your car out of this long-lived misery? Let’s get into it then!

How to Release a Stuck Shifter

The first step to releasing a stuck shifter is connecting the parking brakes, overriding the shift lock, inserting a screwdriver, and pressing the override while pushing the brakes and shifting gears as you usually do. However, before practicing this quick remedy, you must know the root cause. So, what causes the gear shift to get stuck? Here’s everything that you need to know.

Why Is My Gear Shift Stuck? 10 Reasons Why Car Is Stuck in Park

Why Is My Gear Shift Stuck

Let’s get real; you can’t possibly jump straight into the fixes without understanding what causes the gear shift to get stuck in the first place, right? So, here are a few common reasons why this frustrating issue might cause havoc in your daily driving routine. Let’s take a gander.

1. Transmission Fluid

Often the transmission fluid fails, leading to a stuck gear shift. When this occurs, you’ll be hearing an unusual noise at all times and feel the vehicle grinding with delayed shifts.

2. Brake Switch

The shifter interlock might further fumble when the braking switch fails. Brake switches link to the brake pedals, which send electrical signals by pressing the pedal. The message transmits through the system when the brake is pressed. Thus, the brake lights go on.

3. Ignition Switch

When there’s a problem underlying the ignition switch, it will fail to send a general message to your car. Therefore, even when the vehicle is on, the system doesn’t recognize it, and the interlock fails to release the shifter.

4. Shifter Interlock Malfunction

Shifter interlocks prevent cars from going into reverse or driving randomly and are highly useful as safety features. However, to activate this system, you need to start the vehicle, which in return will alert the sensors, solenoids, and the shifter. But, if any of these components malfunction, they will break the sequence needed to activate the shifter interlock, thus making your car motionless.

5. Parking Pawl High Pressure

Parking pawls are integral in every automatic car, and without them, your vehicle will consistently remain neutral and drive away whenever parked. Without a parking pawl’s correct pressure, your vehicle might even drive away when it’s on a hill due to the external forces.

6. Shifter Cables

Manual transmission cars have two cables, whereas automatic vehicles have one. However, a stuck gear can be because these cables get stretched too tight, get too loose or break.

7. Brake Lights

Sometimes when the car is parked, and the brake lights don’t work, there could be a fuse blown or a faulty switch problem somewhere within the system. This can set your car into a park mode and cause shifter issues.

8. Faulty Shifter Solenoid

To check if the solenoid has any underlying issue, you can utilize a digital multimeter. Suppose there’s an open circuit within the solenoid’s wiring. In that case, the mechanism will fail to receive and transmit proper electrical signals, which can lock or unlock the shifter interlock, thus, withholding the entire process.

9. Open Circuit

The next problem is a branch of the former we just discussed. The shifter interlock consists of multiple electrical components and a chain of events.

However, when there’s an open circuit in the interlock, it will cause the car to remain in a parked position. The shifter interlock will fail to provide as needed as the open circuit interrupts the entire communication chain.

10. Limp Mode

A limp mode in a car suggests that the car can’t read any of the signals that the sensors detect. The sensors transmit signals about when to switch the gears or other necessary data via steering wheel. However, due to data inaccuracy, the system will trigger a limp mode that will lock the second and third transmission gear.

Car Still Won’t Shift? Now What?

Car Still Won’t Shift

Let’s say that you’ve reviewed and cross-checked every element of the causes we discussed above. But your car still seems to be on a stubborn drive.

Now what? Keep reading to know a few more reasons for stuck gear shifts that aren’t the most generic.

  • The Weather : When it’s freezing, the temperature drops to lower than zero, which disrupts your transmission’s mechanism. Generally, a frozen solenoid will prevent the gear shift from operating, getting it stuck.
  • Disrupted Safety System: Vehicles are well-equipped with a safety mechanism. Thus, when a car starts and the safety features stand in the way of taking a car out of the parking mode, it can be due to a shift interlock solenoid issue. Since solenoids are metal, every action must be precisely as it will trigger the next step.

Signs That My Car is Not Shifting Properly

Signs That My Car is Not Shifting Properly

You can’t tell that your gear shift is creating havoc if you can’t read the signs first. So, here are a few signs that tell you that the issue is within the gear shift.

  • Whining and Clunking Sounds
    You will feel the car jerk, shake or grind, accompanied by clunking and whining sounds. This can also cause busted starters, flat tires, and transmission issues. The humming and clunking sounds are the neatest in automatic transmissions, discouraging the car from shifting.
  • Unresponsive
    Besides the delays in receiving and mimicking commands, the cars will also be highly unresponsive. Due to this issue, the vehicle will fail to glide into the correct gears every time, leading to clutch problems.
  • Neutral Sounds
    Any sound, excessive or not, should act as an alert to drivers. Neutral sounds can be bumpy and noisy. But, in this case, the issue can also be due to inaccurate fluid levels or when it’s time to replace it.
  • Burning Odor
    When there’s a bad, burning odor coming from the engine, the issue is severe and needs immediate attention. It’s best to check the car thoroughly when this occurs as the underlying problem could be in the transmission fluid, temperature increase, debris accumulation, or corrosion.
  • Engagement Delays
    The most prominent sign of a failing gear shift is delayed engagement in receiving and reciprocating commands. No matter how many times you rev the engine, press the brakes, or clutch, the time needed to fulfill the act will keep delaying.
  • Grinding And Shaking
    Transmission shifts are usually hassle-free. However, while doing so, when the vehicle goes through shaking or grinding, you must understand that something is off.
  • Gear Slips
    A severe problem is gear changes or slips during drives. The driver could select reverse, drive, or neutral, but the gear will slip in any of them, leading to harsh accidents.
  • Clutch Drags
    A troubled automobile’s clutch will drag and slack like no other. This occurs as the clutch disc finds difficulty engaging and disengaging the clutch spinning. It fails to transmit power, thus disobeying the commands.
  • Warning Lights
    Whenever you notice the warning lights illuminated, you need to act quickly. The check engine lights are a dead giveaway that something within the machine is malfunctioning and requires an urgent fix.
  • Fluid Leaks
    Having trouble maintaining the appropriate fluid levels in your car? Well then, there must be a leak somewhere. There are six important fluids inside your car. And in case of leaks from either, you will need to get to the bottom of the issue urgently.

What to Do When Shifter Is Stuck?

What to Do When Shifter Is Stuck

When you understand that the car is stuck, you should try a few things before getting into the problem’s origin. Here are a few steps that you can initially try to release the stuck gear shift.

  • Setting the emergency brakes.
  • Insert keys into ignition and turn it on.
  • Remove cap from the shifter lock override.
  • Insert small objects to push down the slot.
  • Press the braking pedal and shifter.

Potential Causes of a Stuck In Park Condition

Potential Causes of a Stuck In Park Condition

Let’s summarize what we’ve learned so far by telling you some of the potential gear shift malfunctioning causes.

  • Shifter Interlock Malfunctioning due to disrupted electrical, wiring or cable issues.
  • When the car is parked on a hill, the vehicle suffers a high-pressure parking pawl.
  • The ignition switch is faulty or malfunctioning.
  • The braking light or switch is damaged.

General Tips to Avoid Getting Stuck in Park

General Tips to Avoid Getting Stuck in Park

You can get a ton of remedies for this issue. But wouldn’t it be great if you could avoid this altogether? Here’s how you can prevent gear shift issues.

  • Don’t force the shifter to loosen up. Out of sheer frustration, we might tend to jerk the gear. However, this will only lead to more breakage and damages, and it would cost you an arm and a leg to repair the transmission.
  • Are you forgetting to press the brakes? As silly as it sounds, it might be the case, and failing to press the brake beforehand can cause a parking pawl.
  • You’re not using the parking brake when traveling on a hill. And the reason for its importance is that it’s safer than watching your car drive away on its own. Better safe than sorry, right?

Steps to Take if Your Car Is Stuck in Park: How to Fix a Car That’s Stuck

Steps to Take if Your Car Is Stuck in Park

The good news is that there are a few simple steps that you can take to get your car out of this misery. Check out the quick steps below.

  • Step#1:
    Set the parking brakes.
  • Step#2:
    Switch on the ignition without starting the engine.
  • Step#3:
    Disengage the plastic cap atop the shifter console, specifically on the shifter lock override.
  • Step#4:
    Inject a screwdriver into the exposed slot.
  • Step#5:
    Push down on the braking pedal.
  • Step#6:
    Move the shifter.

How To Release An Automatic Gear Shift Stuck In Park: How Does an Automatic Car Park?

How To Release An Automatic Gear Shift Stuck In Park

We’ve seen what causes the gear shift to get stuck on an automatic gear shift, but how to fix them? Check out the quick and easy solutions featured below!

  • Fixing Inclined Parking
    Before applying a parking brake, avoid taking your foot off the pedal. When you take off your feet, move the shifter into the park, thus letting the car hold onto its weight and not disrupt the general pressure rule on a hill.
  • The Brake Lights
    Always ensure that your brake lights have an adequate connection to the switch. Plug it properly for seamless functioning.
  • Shifter Interlock
    To avoid shifter interlocks from malfunctioning, you’ll need to apply force on the brakes to release and free up the locks, so it allows moving out of the parked mode.

What Causes the Gear Shift to Get Stuck Manual/Neutral?

What Causes the Gear Shift to Get Stuck Manual

We know you’re frustrated by the ongoing issues that your car is facing because of the gear shift. And if your gear shift is stuck in neutral or manual, these could be the reasons.

  • Bad shifter cables
  • Transmission fluid or gear oil is low
  • Damaged hub sleeve and synchronizing ring
  • Damaged Master cylinders or gears
  • Low levels of clutch fluid

Why Is My Gear Shift Stuck In Reverse?

Why Is My Gear Shift Stuck In Reverse

Manual drives are all fun and games until the monsters come out. One of the most prominent issues with manual transmission is when it gets stuck in reverse. And here’s why it’s happening.

  • The transmission will be stuck in reverse when the clutch cable isn’t properly extended.
  • Sometimes the extra step needed to shift gears can misalign the transmission’s hardware set, causing it to hit reverse.
  • The gearstick might be damaged.

Car Won’t Shift Out of Drive

Generally, when the car is stuck in drive, the issue lies within a faulty shifter or broken and damaged shifter’s cable. The fixes to these may be similar, but the drivers need to effectively locate the cause.

My Car Will Not Come Out of First Gear

If your car insists on being on the first gear, several things could be why. Some are damaged speed sensors, input shaft’s nut, valves, worn-out clutch, and solenoid or aged transmission fluid.

Gear Shift Is Hard to Move and Keeps Getting Stuck

Usually, when the issue is persistent, it’s because of a faulty hydraulic clutch mechanism. The damages could also be in the synchronizer rings and gearbox. So the first task would be to review the fluid levels in gearbox. And if that doesn’t bear any faults, you must try to release the shifter interlock.

What Does It Mean When Your Car Pops Out of Gear?

If your car pops out of gear, the problem will trace you to damaged and worn-out transmission components. Moreover, worn-out pieces, a bent shifting fork, can also cause these issues.

Final Thoughts

Phew, was that comprehensive! Well, the reasons and fixes behind what causes the gear shift to get stuck is quite a broad subject. But, most importantly, it requires even higher care, aftercare, and maintenance. Drivers who have unwavering love for their rides might break into a sweat when they face gear shift issues.

And rightfully so, as the problem doesn’t only hamper the car’s health but is also hazardous. But, as you now know, the fixes are pretty simple, so why the delay? Go ahead and put your beloved car out of this dreadful misery so you can get a goodnight’s sleep too!

About the author

Michael H. Smith

Michael is the lead content creator for Wheelspick.com. As a car enthusiast and based on his real life experiences he is sharing his opinion about various automotive vehicles and parts. So you can get the best experience! Happy reading.

About The Author

Michael H. Smith

Michael H. Smith

Michael is the lead content creator for Wheelspick.com. As a car enthusiast and based on his real life experiences he is sharing his opinion about various automotive vehicles and parts. So that our reader, can focus solely on buying best gadgets for their automobile and get the best products reviews and guide experience!

Get A Free Quote


www.wheelspick.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. That means we get a commission through purchases made through our links.

Recent Posts

Why Won't My Jeep Start
Why Won’t My Jeep Start [10 Common Reasons and Fixes]
December 8, 2022
Steering Wheel Squeaks When Turning
Why Steering Wheel Squeaks When Turning [A Quick Way To Fix]
October 21, 2021
Why Is My Tire Losing Air Overnight
Why Is My Tire Losing Air Overnight [15 Reasons Why]
December 15, 2022
Why Do Electric Cars Accelerate Faster
Why Do Electric Cars Accelerate Faster [Explained in Simple Terms]
November 3, 2022
What to do with Expired Car Seats
What to Do with Expired Car Seats: Dispose and Recycle Techniques
January 20, 2022
What to Do When Your Steering Wheel Locks;
What to Do When Your Steering Wheel Locks [5 Strategies For Beginners]
March 31, 2022
What to Do When You Get New Tires
What to Do When You Get New Tires [10 Things To Do]
December 29, 2022
What to Do About Car Seats When Traveling
What to Do About Car Seats When Traveling [10 Things to Know]
March 9, 2023
What Jeep Has the Best Gas Mileage
What Jeep Has the Best Gas Mileage: 5 Most Gas Efficient Jeep
October 7, 2022
What is my Jeep Worth
What is my Jeep Worth [Know the Value of Your Jeep]
November 24, 2022
What Is an Air Compressor Used for in a Car
What Is an Air Compressor Used for in a Car: 20 Surprising Uses
September 22, 2022
What Happens When TPMS Battery Dies
What Happens When TPMS Battery Dies [What You Should Know About It]
September 17, 2023
what happens when power steering pump goes out;
What Happens When Power Steering Pump Goes Out: Causes and Fixes
March 10, 2022
What Does It Mean When Your Steering Wheel Shakes
What Does It Mean When Your Steering Wheel Shakes
December 2, 2021
What Does a Track Bar Do on a Jeep
What Does a Track Bar Do on a Jeep: Why Do You Need It?
September 15, 2022

Related Posts

Leave a Reply